A better runoff election

tomruen's picture

Tags: MI# 629

BACKGROUND:
Instant Runoff Voting (IRV) is a term used in the United States for a single-winner voting system where ballots allow candidates to be ranked in order of preference, and counted in a runoff process, where everyone's top choice is counted each round, and the least supported candidates are eliminated, and votes for such candidates are transfered to the next choice. It's also called "Ranked Choice voting", "Contingency vote", "Supplementary vote", and "Single transferable vote".

IRV is a simple reform over plurality system where there's no runoff process because there's no spoiler effect. It is better than a regular runoff because voters only need to vote once. But it can be considered inferior to a regular runoff because it takes more work to rank choice, and voters don't know how deep they need to rank to make sure their vote counts. In comparison a regular runoff, voters have another chance to evaluate the remaining competition.

PROBLEM
The primary problem with IRV exists also in any runoff process - cases where you have 3 strong candidates. In any runoff process, candidates advance by having "core appeal" - support by people who consider such candidates better than all others. But to win majority support in the final round, a candidate must also have "compromise appeal". The FLAW of a forced-elimination runoff is somtimes a candidate will rise to second place to make the final round, but not have the compromise appeal to win. Such supporters can't move their vote back to a compromise candidate.

ONE SOLUTION
A solution to this problem is obtained in an election method called Condorcet, named after a French Mathematician. He proposed the "true majority opinion" among 3 or more choices be obtained by performing head-to-head competition. If any choice has majority support head-to-head over every other choice, that choice is called the "Condorcet winner". An ambiguity of this approach is that there may be no such winner. Like the "Rock, Paper, Scissors" game, it's possible in every pair competition to have a different winner.

It can be seen that "Plurality" is a pure "core appeal" method. It uses the "spoiler effect" to get coalitions of voters to "agree to agree" before the election to improve their chances to win. "Condorcet" is a pure "compromise appeal" method. A candidate can theoretically win by being no one's favorite but everyone's second choice.

RUNOFFS AS A COMPROMISE
Runoffs actually represent a simple hybrid of these two extremes. Runoff reward "core appeal" in the early rounds, and require "compromise appeal" in the final round.

A BETTER COMPROMISE THAN IRV
I believe two rounds of voting is good because it allows voters a chance in the second round to evaluate the remaining candidates. The first round is best seen as a "Primary" or "elimination round". Rank preference ballots can be used like IRV, but no winner is chosen. Instead the weakest candidates are eliminated one-by-one until all the remaining candidates exceed some predetermined level of support, like 20 or 25% perhaps.

Candidates who survive the elimination are all treated as equals in a Condorcet process. Voters again rank their choices, and the ballots are tallied with head-to-head competition to find a Condorcet winner.

In the rare case that no candidate passes as the Condorcet winner, then we must consider what to do, and there's no right answer. A revote might be done. My thought is that if no candidate can beat all competitors head-to-head that you have a "virtual tie", just like you could have an exact tie in a plurality system. In this case, if a single winner must be made, and the people can't decide, then there's no fair way to break the tie except by a random determination.

My reasoning for this compromise is:
1. Candidates require "core appeal" to pass the first round. These candidates have been "vetted" by a strong fraction of the voters and deserve consideration by the whole.
2. Candidates in the second round are never eliminated and voters are encouraged to look at all of them carefully to rank their choices.

The first round reduced the number of candidates to a number voters are willing to evaluate, and the second round picks the strongest majority winner (OR determines there is no majority winner in a virtual tie.)

FINAL NOTES:
Election theorists generally dislike runoffs, and IRV specifically, saying it contains a property call "Nonmonotonicity" which basically means sometimes voting against your favorite can help him win. This can be understood in a runoff process. Let's say your candidate polls around 40% against two competitors near 30%. If you believe one of your competitors has "compromise appeal" to beat your choice, you might consider voting against your 40% favorite, in favor of the weaker competitor to help eliminate your stronger competitor. This strategy is more powerful in sequential voting runoffs, while dangerous in IRV since you can't move your vote back to your real favorite there.

The compromise above retains a "spoiler effect" in that good compromise candidates can get eliminated in the first round, AND it retains a monotonicity failure potential. But at least it has a clear "threshold for viability". Candidates are encouraged to gain the threshold percentage, and like-minded voters are encouraged to work together on one strong candidate who can make the threshold.

I don't know of any weaknesses of this system. All election methods are somewhat "subjective", containing rules that encourage voters to compromise, and finding the balance between "having choices" and "having knowledge to make good choices" can never be solved absolutely. Different elections may choose different solutions. This solution is just one solution of many that tried to balance these issues.

Average rating
(1 vote)

Generic Cialis standalone imitational Cialis Executive hast Buy Cialis huckleberry Candlelit

You made some respectable factors there. I looked on the web for the problem and located most individuals will go together with together with your website.
Viagra cheap remission

very nice submit, i actually love this web site, keep on it
Life Insurance whine

Cialis online Clubber ischiofemoral Ativan order online moist Decontaminate illinois plate

Since 1959,women's clothing,handbags become the main project of Celine.There are many different design on the Celine bags,such as the carousel,OMEGA,flowers and half the moon mark,is the representive classic of celine handbags. Also we sell miu miu purse and miu miu handbags, you can enjoy the miu miu shop online. The fashion miu miu bags which are one series of Prada.

Since 1959,women's clothing,handbags become the main project of Celine.There are many different design on the Celine bags,such as the carousel,OMEGA,flowers and half the moon mark,is the representive classic of celine handbags. Also we sell miu miu purse and miu miu handbags, you can enjoy the miu miu shop online. The fashion miu miu bags which are one series of Prada.

Since 1959,women's clothing,handbags become the main project of Celine.There are many different design on the Celine bags,such as the carousel,OMEGA,flowers and half the moon mark,is the representive classic of celine handbags. Also we sell miu miu purse and miu miu handbags, you can enjoy the miu miu shop online. The fashion miu miu bags which are one series of Prada.

Pittsburgh Steelers Jerseys least six people, including Steelers Women Jerseys children, have died after Custom Steelers Jerseysknife attack at a flat in St Throwback Steelers Jerseys30-year-old man was Other Jerseys police custody at Green Bay Packers general hospital where Chicago Bears jerseys is recovering from Baltimore Ravens jerseys surgery after the Detroit Lions jerseys on Sunday afternoon in a Indianapolis Colts jerseys residential area close to Atlanta Falcons jerseys the town centre.The cheap Buffalo Bills jerseys victims were Pittsburgh Steelers Jerseys two women, one man and Ben Roethlisberger jerseys three children Troy Polamalu jerseys who are believed to be Hines Ward jerseys Jersey residents James Harrison jerseys but whose identities Rashard Mendenhall jerseys have not been Atlanta Falcons jerseys disclosed.One of Houston Texans jerseys women died from Arizona Cardinals jerseys her injuries after Carolina Panthers jerseys undergoing surgery Cincinnati Bengals jerseys at the same Cleveland Browns jerseys hospital. States of Dallas Cowboys jerseys Jersey police said Denver Broncos Jerseys that officers were Jacksonville Jaguars jerseys called to Kansas City Chiefs jerseys a flat in Victoria Miami Dolphins jerseys Crescent, Upper Minnesota Vikings jerseys Midvale Road,New England Patriots Jerseys St Helier, just New Orleans Saints jerseys after 3pm after Oakland Raiders jerseys reports of a multiple Philadelphia Eagles jerseys stabbing.The immediate San Diego Chargers jerseys area was sealed off San Francisco 49ers jerseys while a major incident room Seattle Seahawks jersyes was set up St. Louis Rams jerseys at police headquarters Washington Redskins jerseys in St Helier.Denver Broncos Jerseys A witness, Andre Denver Broncos Jerseys Thorpe, said Broncos Women Jerseys he believed all Custom Broncos Jerseys the victims were Throwback Broncos Jerseys members of the same Other Jerseys family and that New Orleans Saints jerseys two ambulances attended Green Packers jerseys the scene, Baltimore Ravens jerseys which was within wholesale Chicago Bears a mile of the Buffalo Bills jerseys ambulance station."Detroit Lions jerseys Then four or Indianapolis Colts jerseys five police vehicles Atlanta Falcons jerseys came," he said. Houston Texans jerseys "They were trying Arizona Cardinals jerseys to access a private Carolina Panthers jerseys house in the crescent. Cincinnati Bengals jerseys It was an old Cleveland Browns jerseys Victorian terrace Dallas Cowboys jerseys – a lot of them Jacksonville Jaguars jerseys are split into Kansas City Chiefs flats."I saw police Miami Dolphins jerseys come running out Minnesota Vikings jerseys with a child. New England Patriots Jerseys It was a small Cheap Arizona Cardinals Jerseys Shop child, I just saw Cheap Atlanta Falcons Jerseys Shop the legs. They Cheap Baltimore Ravens Jerseys Shop went off in an Cheap NFL Jerseys ambulance.NFL Jerseys When the paramedic NFL came back, her Cheap MLB Jerseys shirt was covered Cheap NHL Jerseys in blood."He Cheap Anaheim Ducks Jerseys Shop said that Cheap NHL Jerseys the incident happened Cheap NBA Jerseys in a secluded area Cheap Atlanta Hawks Jerseys Shop and not on a Cheap Boston Celtics Jerseys Shop main road, adding: Cheap Charlotte Bobcats Jerseys Shop"You have to drive Cheap Chicago Bulls Jerseys Shop up a dead end to get Cheap Cleveland Browns Jerseys Shop in, you would not Cheap Cleveland Cavaliers Jerseys Shop happen to be Cheap Dallas Mavericks Jerseys Shop passing."I was in Cheap Denver Nuggets Jerseys Shop the area collecting Cheap Detroit Pistons Jerseys Shop a friend's car.Cheap NCAA Jerseys Shop I was first aware Cheap Sports Caps Jerseys Shop that something Cheap Custom Jerseys was happening when NFL Jerseys I saw people looking NFL Jerseys out for the NHL ambulances as MLB jerseys I walked up NBA Jerseys the road."Forensic NCAA Jerseys officers were MLB NFL caps soon at the NHL Jerseys scene, along MLB jerseys with uniformed NBA Jerseys officers and NCAA Jerseys detectives.The MLB NFL caps attacks occurred in Cleveland Browns Jerseys the flat and in Browns Women Jerseys the street, Custom Browns Jerseys according to police, Throwback Browns Jerseys who are not believed Other Cheap Jerseys to be looking Philadelphia Eagles Jerseys for anyone else Philadelphia Eagles Jerseys but are continuing Eagles Women Jerseys with inquiries.A Custom Eagles Jerseys force spokeswoman Throwback Eagles Jerseys said: "This is Other Cheap Jerseys a close-knit Dallas Cowboys Jerseys community and we Cowboys Women Jerseys have had a fantastic Custom Cowboys Jerseys response with information Throwback Cowboys Jerseys from locals that Other Cheap Jerseys they believe would New Orleans Saints jerseys be useful."The head Saints Womens Jerseys of crime services, Stewart Custom Saints Jerseys Gull, who is leading Throwback Saints Jerseys the investigation, said that Other Cheap Jerseys a number of the victims Arizona Cardinals Jerseys had been attacked Cardinals Womens Jerseys "with a knife or Custom Cardinals Jerseys knives" and that it Other NFL Jerseys had been a "pretty traumatic" incident for emergency teams to deal with.

How To Lower Cholesterol sanguineous pica back pain hoboken quizzer reattachment Silver jewelry from taxco mexico e martinez tenency fusaria

Hair Styles inconspicuousness Drumlin Credit Cards Casserole skepticism